Michael Heiser’s material on women in ministry is worth revisiting, especially as a window into how he wrestled with topics and shifted his viewpoint as he did so. In his early posts, Heiser described himself as basically complementarian, but with significant qualifications. He took the relevant biblical data seriously, admitted where arguments were not as airtight as people wanted them to be, and repeatedly refused to bind consciences where he did not think the text gave him that kind of clarity.
In the below posts, you can see him wrestling with the issue in public. Phoebe, Junia, Deborah, 1 Corinthians 14, 1 Timothy 2, women prophesying, deacons, elders, pastors, house churches all get considered. Part of the value of these posts is watching him refuse simplistic answers.
Later than these blog posts, in an AWKNG Q&A, Heiser locates his resolution in a broader biblical-theological frame: Eden. His question became, in effect: before the fall, who was created to be God’s servant-steward ruler in sacred space—the man or the woman?
His answer: yes.
That Edenic ideal became, for him, the controlling issue.
Below is a table of contents for these posts and the AWKNG Q&A as well as a guide to this information and related resources on women in ministry.
Heiser’s Posts on Women in Ministry
These are now internally linked together within the posts so you can jump from one to other and read them in chronological order of posting; but you may want to scroll down to a recommended reading order to make sense of the positions in general.
Romans 16:7: Implications for Egalitarian-Complementarian Debate
Reexamination of Phoebe as 'Diakonos' and 'Prostatis'
Women in Ministry: Is There a Biblical View?
Responding to John Hobbins on Women as Ministers
Women as Ministers: Resources and Scattered Thoughts
Women in Ministry: Response to John Hobbins
Women in Ministry: Next Round with John Hobbins
A Thanks to John Hobbins on the Women in Ministry Issue
Naked Bible Podcast 130 - ETS: Image/Idols, Women & the Church
Larry Hurtado and Peter Gurry on Payne’s Study of 1 Cor 14:34-35
Later Reflection: The Edenic Ideal
In a later AWKNG Q&A, Heiser revisited the women-in-ministry question and explained where the issue had come to rest for him. He acknowledged that the usual passages—Phoebe, Junia, Deborah, 1 Timothy 2, 1 Corinthians 14, deacons, elders, prophecy, and priesthood—can be argued in detail from both sides.
But for Heiser, the decisive frame became Eden. Before the fall, the man and the woman were both created as God’s image-bearing servant-steward rulers. That Edenic ideal, he said, was what resolved the issue in his own mind.
Suggested Reading Order
If you are new to the discussion, here’s a suggested reading order:
- “Women in Ministry: Is There a Biblical View?”
This is the best starting point because Heiser lays out the issue and explains where he was at the time. - The John Hobbins exchange
These posts show Heiser actively engaging pushback, refining his thoughts, and clarifying what he was and was not saying. - The posts on Junia and Phoebe
These fill in two of the most important Romans 16 texts often raised in the egalitarian/complementarian debate. - The 1 Corinthians 14 post
This is useful because it shows Heiser did not read “women should keep silent” as a simple universal gag order. - Naked Bible Podcast / ETS-SBL interview with Lynn Cohick
This is not Heiser laying out his own women-in-ministry position in the same way the blog posts do, but it is valuable supplemental material. The interview points readers toward historical work on women’s authority, influence, theological activity, and ministry in the early church. - The AWKNG Q&A clip (embedded above)
This is where Heiser’s later position becomes clearest. He acknowledges that many of the standard arguments can be made and answered on both sides, but says the Edenic ideal is what resolves the issue in his own mind.
The value of this collection is not merely that it tells us “which side” Heiser landed on as if we need to agree with him. It shows how he got there.
Heiser modeled something rare in theological debate: public wrestling without needing to be dogmatic. He admitted uncertainty; he allowed arguments to develop; he refused bad arguments even when they supported the side he was closer to at the time; and when his thinking shifted, it shifted because he was trying to follow the text and the biblical storyline.
Whether readers agree with Heiser’s final framing or not, these posts are a good example of how to approach a contested issue with careful examination.
Further Reading Across the Debate
For readers who want to keep digging, the following works offer a broader range of perspectives on women in ministry, Paul’s letters, early Christianity, and the egalitarian/complementarian debate.
Some links below are affiliate links, which means we may earn a small commission if you purchase through them, at no additional cost to you. We do not endorse all the views here, but include them as helpful resources for readers who want to explore the debate further.
A Balanced Starting Point
James R. Beck, ed., Two Views on Women in Ministry
A helpful place to begin because it presents both major evangelical positions in conversation with each other. Readers who want to understand the debate without starting in only one camp may find this the best first stop.
Gregg R. Allison, Complementarity: Dignity, Difference, and Interdependence
A broad evangelical complementarian treatment from a systematic theologian. Unlike resources focused mainly on 1 Timothy 2 or church office, Allison frames the discussion more widely around creation, image-bearing, difference, interdependence, the church, and Christian discipleship.
Egalitarian / Mutualist Perspectives
Cynthia Long Westfall, Paul and Gender
A substantial exegetical treatment of Paul’s letters from an egalitarian perspective. This is especially useful for readers who want to think carefully about Paul’s language, context, and argumentation.
Philip B. Payne, Man and Woman, One in Christ
A major egalitarian work that addresses many of the key disputed passages, including 1 Corinthians 14 and 1 Timothy 2. Payne is especially relevant because Heiser linked to discussion of Payne’s work on whether 1 Corinthians 14:34–35 is original to Paul’s letter.
Ronald W. Pierce, Cynthia Long Westfall, and Christa L. McKirland, eds., Discovering Biblical Equality
A wide-ranging collection of essays making the case for biblical equality. This is useful for readers who want a broader theological, exegetical, historical, and practical treatment.
Lynn H. Cohick and Amy Brown Hughes, Christian Women in the Patristic World
A historical study of women’s influence, ministry, martyrdom, theological activity, and leadership in the early church. This is especially relevant because Heiser interviewed Cohick on the Naked Bible Podcast.
Sandra L. Glahn, Nobody’s Mother: Artemis of the Ephesians in Antiquity and the New Testament
A focused study of Artemis of the Ephesians and how Ephesian religious background may inform the interpretation of 1 Timothy. Glahn argues that better historical context helps readers approach difficult Pauline texts without flattening them into generic rules about women. This is especially useful as a companion to discussions of 1 Timothy 2 and Paul’s instructions in Ephesus.
Complementarian Perspectives
Andreas J. Köstenberger and Thomas R. Schreiner, eds., Women in the Church
One of the major complementarian treatments of 1 Timothy 2:9–15. This is an important resource for readers who want to understand the exegetical case often made against women serving as elders or pastors..
Wayne Grudem, Evangelical Feminism and Biblical Truth
A broad complementarian response to egalitarian arguments, covering marriage, church leadership, authority, teaching, prophecy, and disputed biblical texts.
Focused Textual-Critical Resource
Philip B. Payne on 1 Corinthians 14:34–35
For academic-level readers interested specifically in the question of whether “women should keep silent in the churches” was original to Paul’s letter, Payne’s work on 1 Corinthians 14:34–35 is one of the major reference points. Heiser’s own post points readers into this debate, and it is worth exploring separately from the broader women-in-ministry question.
Bonus!
Here is a video from Dr. Carmen Imes about recent books on women in the Bible and in church.
0 Comments